Farmed Salmon vs. Wild Salmon: The Great Debate

Like most debates, the farmed vs. wild salmon debate is complex. When comparing farmed salmon vs wild salmon, we have to consider a multitude of factors, and even then it’s not possible to label one kind as “better” in all instances! In fact, there are so many factors to consider we won’t try to address them in one blog post (even our eyes would glaze over!). Here’s the first comparison post where we focus on taste and culinary factors of farmed vs. wild salmon. Stay tuned for other posts comparing cost, availability, sustainability/responsibility, nutrition and quality.


Which tastes better: farmed salmon vs wild salmon?

Farmed salmon tends to have a milder taste, and a more tender texture, which makes it more popular with a lot of people. Farmed-raised salmon also have big, fleshy sections of intramuscular fat that create easily flaked and moist pieces once cooked.

Wild Salmon has a much more pronounced and strong fish flavor, which is absolutely loved and sought after by many home cooks and chefs! However, the stronger flavor can sometimes be off-putting, so it is a matter of preference.

Which is easier to cook: farmed salmon vs wild salmon?

Generally speaking, farmed salmon is easier to cook. That’s because it tends to be fattier, with thicker fillets on average, making it more forgiving no matter the cooking application.

Wild salmon tends to be leaner with more muscle fibers, making it a bit firmer than farmed salmon. These attributes make it easier to overcook wild salmon so it’s dry, rubbery and extra forward on the “fishiness” factor.


Summary taste & cooking for farmed salmon vs wild salmon

For all of the reasons above, which are generalizations, many people prefer the taste and texture of farmed salmon. However, no matter if a fish is farmed or wild, a healthy fish will always create the best end product, and to some degree flavor and texture depends on the species, its diet, the specific farming practices and environment, etc.

Get to know our farm-raised, Icelandic salmon

Taste and Cooking: farmed salmon vs wild salmon

Farmed  Wild 
  • Generally more forgiving
    • The higher fat and thicker fillets make it harder to overcook
  • Milder flavor 
  • Buttery, more tender texture 
  • Can be certified parasite-free if raised in saltwater, and ready for raw or medium-rare cooking preparations 


  • Can be less forgiving difficult to cook 
    • Leaner fillets and less fat content mean wild salmon can be harder to cook just right
  • Stronger flavor 
  • Leaner and firmer texture
  • Recommended to cook wild salmon at least to medium to kill any parasites 
Sign up for our newsletter!
  • niceland-packaging

Digital Menus Help Educate Diners

Digital Menus Help Educate Diners An outcome of pandemic-era dining? The rise of the QR code and digital menus. That’s right - QR codes are finally having their moment in the U.S., and largely due to the exposure diners (of every generation) receive each time they sit down at a table for dine-in service. While we miss the tailor-made, classic experience of [...]

October 27th, 2020|News|
  • 10k-otr-vacuum-seal

What is a 10K OTR Film? Why should you care about a vacuum seal?

What is a 10K OTR Film? Why should you care about a vacuum seal? Have you ever wondered why you see directions to remove frozen fish from its vacuum seal package while thawing? Well, the answer is simple: in packaging without 10K OTR plastic film (we’ll get to that below), if you don’t remove the vacuum seal, the temperature becomes too warm, [...]

August 20th, 2020|News, Sustainability|
  • king-kampachi-inside-the-net

Introducing Niceland Kampachi

Introducing Niceland Kampachi Exciting news! We’ve partnered with a pristine, ASC-certified farm in Baja Sur (that’s right!) called King Kampachi to bring their special fish to home cooks everywhere. This fish is sought after by the world’s top chefs, and starting August 11th home cooks can order it for the first time via Crowd Cow. The King Kampachi team raises its fish [...]

August 5th, 2020|News, Sustainability|